The panel brought together Dr. Doris Röhl, Senior Investment Strategist, Pensionskasse Stadt Zürich; Hagen Raab, Managing Director, KKR Global Client Solutions, Territory Head of DACH & Head of KKR Switzerland GmbH; Jens Witzke, Head of Private Credit Sales, Deutsche Asset Management; and Adrian Schatzmann, CEO, Asset Management Association Switzerland (AMAS). Moderated by Andreas Schaffner.
The moderator's opening question was deliberately pointed: what holds Swiss pension funds back most from private markets today – regulation, governance, liquidity or cost? Hagen Raab, Managing Director, KKR Global Client Solutions and Head of KKR Switzerland, who had given the keynote just before, questioned the premise. Swiss investors have good experience with private markets and are adding infrastructure and private debt alongside private equity. In the past the hurdle was mainly implementation, as many teams were very small. Transparency, education and experience have since increased, contributing to greater familiarity with private markets.
Adrian Schatzmann, CEO of AMAS, saw the gap mainly at smaller funds, where resources and expertise are missing. An investment team of three or four people used to listed securities cannot simply «push a button» and start doing private credit or infrastructure. Jens Witzke, Head of Private Credit Sales at Deutsche Asset Management, pointed to complexity, higher costs than tradable instruments and the need to match liquidity to liabilities. What has changed in recent months, he said, is a «tsunami» of governance requirements: due diligence by clients has intensified massively, driven by regulation and supervisors' questions.
Dr. Doris Röhl, Senior Investment Strategist at the City of Zurich Pension Fund, described what entering the asset class looks like in practice. PKZH had been investing in private equity for around ten years when a 2017 ALM study identified private debt as a sensible addition to its credit allocation. It entered in 2018. Private debt sits below investment grade: the borrowers are companies bought by private equity funds with borrowed money. That requires solid knowledge of the asset class and good advisors for fund selection.
From the outset PKZH wanted to invest in a very traditional, «langweilig» way, as Röhl put it in German: senior secured loans only, no junior debt, nothing sophisticated or distressed. Secured lenders have much better recovery prospects when a credit goes wrong, as a comparison of loss rates with unsecured high yield shows. So far the fund has had no losses, though she acknowledged that the past four or five years have been good ones.
Within the portfolio, private debt complements the liquid credit side of investment grade and high yield bonds. PKZH uses two building blocks: syndicated loans, which are more liquid, and direct lending through closed-end funds without liquidity. As a long-term investor the fund does not need that liquidity, and the risk-return profile is attractive. Today 4% of its assets are in private debt.
The moderator put to Jens Witzke an earlier statement from his firm that investors are currently not paid more for credit risk in private markets than in public markets. Witzke put it in context. In highly competitive segments such as senior direct lending to software companies, competition had built up over two years, with higher leverage, covenant-light structures and compressed spreads; what happened in that sector at the start of 2026 could be anticipated. There, the premium is indeed not attractive compared with other parts of the market.
Access makes the difference, he argued. A manager with a strong origination franchise that reaches other sectors, such as Europe's re-industrialisation, can protect margins and covenants. Senior direct lending currently offers 525 to 550 basis points of spread plus structuring fees, about 200 basis points over tradable high yield, with a different sector mix that adds diversification.
Röhl added the investor's view: «My boss would not be happy if I said we are replacing high yield with private debt.» PKZH holds both because it also needs liquidity. Within direct lending there are three markets – lower, mid and upper – with different covenants and spreads. Investors need to be in the right segment and diversify within it.
Hagen Raab linked back to his keynote. A pension fund's first duty remains meeting its long-term obligations to beneficiaries and preserving capital. That is why diversification should be considered more broadly: across asset classes, investment strategies and regions. Raab pointed to infrastructure opportunities across Asia, including India, where KKR has invested in essential infrastructure assets. He noted that the region comprises economies at different stages of development, with distinct growth drivers and infrastructure investment needs.
Turning to private equity, Raab noted that attractive investments have become harder to find, particularly through competitive auction processes. He emphasised the value of building trusted partnerships with business owners. He cited KKR's investment in OHB as an example of how private equity investors can support businesses through operational expertise, international networks and M&A capabilities.
Later, he added a broader macroeconomic point: given high levels of government debt, private capital has a role to play in financing modernisation and new infrastructure, while public-private partnerships could help address investment needs.
In the regulatory block, Adrian Schatzmann set out the AMAS position. The BVV 2 ordinance has a 15% limit for alternative investments that groups together hedge funds, private markets, gold and more. Gold is highly liquid and has nothing in common with private markets. He did not claim that the framework keeps investors out; those who want to go beyond 15% do so. The flaw is subtler: exceed the limit and you have to explain yourself, while a fund holding 100% in Swiss government bonds yielding close to nothing does not. The framework gives a false sense of security and asks neither whether a fund uses its risk capacity nor how it performs.
Rather than going straight to a prudent investor rule, AMAS proposes a modernisation. Public and private equity have more in common than private equity and gold, since in both cases the investor becomes an owner of a company. Each asset class – equities, fixed income, real estate – should have a public and a private sleeve. How much goes into each would depend on market expectations, risk appetite and, above all, liquidity needs.
Challenged that AMAS was simply speaking for the managers selling these products, Schatzmann accepted the question. The association does not advocate for any asset class, and «more private markets is better» would be a silly message. AMAS speaks up where the claim is «lower cost is better». What matters is net performance after costs. A fund could minimise costs by holding 100% cash, which would be wrong. Private markets products become more expensive the more successful they are; rejecting them because they are expensive is the wrong approach.
PKZH shows that a small team can be enough. Röhl joined from the German private debt market and works with one deputy. Running its own due diligence with manager visits across the US and Europe would not have been feasible. PKZH therefore ran an extensive RFP and, after about a year, selected a consultant. Together they set the guidelines (senior secured only, no junior loans), the target allocation and the timeline.
In the first phase the consultant held an advisory mandate: it proposed every investment, discussed it with the fund and presented it to the investment committee, so the committee could learn about the asset class too. After four years it was given a discretionary mandate, but it still consults the internal team. The fund needs people in-house who know the asset class and can challenge the consultant, Röhl said.
Jens Witzke placed this in an international context. In Canada, Denmark or Finland, investors started pragmatically around two decades ago because they had return targets to meet, and built their teams over time. Very large institutions now run their own origination teams and co-invest. For most, a hybrid model combining in-house and external expertise makes sense.
Valuations are the topic of the year, Witzke said, referring to the volatility in certain sectors and vehicles at the beginning of 2026. Investors should check at least three things. First, a manager's underwriting principles, for instance its use of PIK (payment-in-kind) components: using them from day one defers income and dilutes current cash flow. Second, risk management: Deutsche Asset Management puts a position on its watchlist once it deviates 10% from the credit case, downwards or upwards, and around 20% of its investments are on the list at any time. Third, the valuation process: external ratings and an independent valuation agent help managers stay self-critical about their own investments.
Asked about perception gaps, Raab said private markets and regions such as Asia are often seen as potentially risky. A single young technology company can carry significant risk, while diversification can help mitigate the risk of losses. Risk profiles also vary considerably within individual asset classes.
In infrastructure the range goes from a developer without financing to an existing asset with a long-term, inflation-linked contract with the regulator and fixed financing. Risk depends not only on the asset class, but also on the underlying investment strategy and characteristics of the asset.
Röhl advises smaller funds to first be clear about why private debt fits their portfolio, then outsource implementation to consultants and hire one person in-house with knowledge of the asset class – an approach that also keeps costs manageable. Schatzmann's advice to foundation boards: make sure decision-makers get the education they need, and make no investment without understanding it. What to avoid: ignoring private markets simply because you have done so for the last 20 years.
Private debt and private equity count as alternative investments under Art. 53 para. 1 let. e BVV 2 and share the 15% limit with hedge funds, insurance-linked securities and other investments (Art. 55 let. d BVV 2). Since October 2020 infrastructure has had its own category with a 10% limit (Art. 55 let. f BVV 2). Higher allocations are possible under the extension clause in Art. 50 para. 4 BVV 2, provided the fund demonstrates conclusively in the notes to its annual accounts that safety and risk diversification are maintained. The AMAS proposal of public and private sleeves per asset class is the association's position, not current law. Figures on spreads and the watchlist are from Deutsche Asset Management; those on PKZH are from Dr. Doris Röhl.
Panel «An Institutional View on Private Markets», Swiss Institutional Symposium 2026, 10 November 2026, Mandarin Oriental Savoy, Zurich. With Dr. Doris Röhl (Pensionskasse Stadt Zürich), Hagen Raab (KKR), Jens Witzke (Deutsche Asset Management) and Adrian Schatzmann (AMAS); moderated by Andreas Schaffner. · Ordinance on Occupational Retirement, Survivors' and Disability Pension Plans (BVV 2) of 18 April 1984, SR 831.441.1. Note: figures on spreads, returns and portfolios are statements by the panellists and do not constitute investment advice. Past performance is not an indicator of future results.